Adirondacks history news Political History Politics St Lawrence County

Gouverneur’s Rhoda Fox Graves, NYS Political Trailblazer (Part 3) –

Gouverneur’s Rhoda Fox Graves, NYS Political Trailblazer (Part 3) -

After a yr in workplace, Rhoda Graves gained reelection to the New York State Assembly, while 5 other feminine GOP candidates elsewhere in the state lost. In January 1926, she sought the chairmanship of the social welfare committee, a position already held by a senior member (from Niagara) who was unwilling to give up it. She was as an alternative given cost of public establishments — not her choice, for positive — but chairing any committee was one other historic first for New York ladies.

Rhoda’s second yr in workplace was an lively one. She pushed a invoice proscribing the slaughter of tubercular cows to their house county moderately than performing the job at a central location; was in a critical practice derailment that killed the engineer, but she and Perle emerged relatively unscathed; argued for greater tariffs on incoming farm goods to guard locals; was reelected vice-chairman of the County Republican Committee; and gained reelection to the Meeting.

In 1927, her legislative objectives included: including a gasoline tax to fund development of county and state roads; as an alternative of ending county roads at village perimeters, extending them via villages to attach with state highways; banning reveals of butter substitutes at local, county, and state festivals (substitutes harm the incomes of farmers); abolishing the 30-day-resident voting rule in districts that didn’t require private registration (shifting day in New York for hundreds who rented farms was November 1, just before Election Day); a bill to separate the town of Oswegatchie from the town of Ogdensburg; and the appropriation of $1 million to nationally advertise in the US and Canada the wonders to tour in New York State. She also visited sites throughout the district, stayed in touch with constituents, and spoke typically at public occasions during what was her third Meeting term — once more, unprecedented for ladies.

The next yr, 1928, she sponsored bills supporting the equal remedy of men and women regarding welfare and guardianship rights. A few of the proposals she acted on got here from the National Ladies’s Get together, of which Rhoda was a member, and the League of Ladies Voters. A serious coup was official recognition of her past success: Rhoda’s technique of organizing ladies was adopted on a statewide foundation by the GOP, which despatched a replica of her course of to each county chairman in New York. (As vice-chairman of the St. Lawrence County Committee, she had organized the county’s 32 cities and 113 election districts, appointing a lady chair in each city and a lady consultant in every district.)

At every alternative, including many talking engagements, she reached out to other ladies, encouraging them to enter politics, which, she stated, “Is a way to a greater life. State authorities is simply housekeeping on a big scale.” And it was true. Historically, ladies had managed the house and addressed everybody’s complaints and wishes, which was primarily the job of legislators on a statewide basis. She applied that notion first to her own district constituents, after which to New Yorkers usually, which is why, despite being solidly Republican, she supported packages that some colleagues deemed socialism. However what mattered to her at first was serving the needs of North Country people, so if poverty or another need was a problem, she sought legislative options. The celebration’s needs got here second.

It was troublesome to overstate the value of Rhoda Graves when it came to the continued battle by ladies for equal rights, for even in 1929, her fifth yr in office, she was the one feminine member of New York’s legislature. Early in the yr, pictures of the Equal Rights motion leaders, together with Rhoda, appeared in lots of newspapers, accompanied by their agenda. She pursued numerous those objectives that included equality in serving on juries (solely males might serve on the time), earning old-age pensions, receiving compensation for a variety of occupational illnesses, allowing separate authorized domiciles from husbands (by regulation, solely men might have them), allowing ladies to work after 10 p.m. in eating places, and, men aside on this one, offering access to contraceptive info.

In February, her Meeting position seemed to be in jeopardy as a consequence of a reapportionment plan that may mix two northern districts, forcing her right into a runoff election. Nevertheless, the proposal, virtually similar to at least one vetoed by Governor Al Smith in 1926, was vetoed again, this time by Governor Franklin Roosevelt. It wasn’t the first time her future was challenged, and it wouldn’t be the last.

It was additionally in February that she gained an enormous victory for Gouverneur associated to the development of a 20-foot-wide cement street by way of the village, the trail of which had grow to be controversial. She consulted with the state highway commissioner, who agreed to construct the highway as requested, “from one extremity of the village to the other.”

In April, her bill establishing the New York State Bureau of Publicity was signed into regulation by the governor, laying the groundwork for wide-scale promotional efforts that continue immediately by means of numerous state entities and have brought untold billions of dollars value of business to New York. The Adirondacks and foothills have benefited immeasurably from such advertising campaigns.

In early 1930, the New York Solar addressed her personal life in an interview revealed beneath the headline, New York’s Only Lady Member of Meeting is “Rhody” to Neighbors. “Why should a lady feel misplaced,” she stated, “in helping look after the welfare of the group she represents? The individuals of that group elect her; she is there to characterize each women and men, and persons of all political parties. And a lady should welcome a chance to serve the individuals of her county in the legislature…. My house has by no means suffered via my public activities. I was at residence when my two sons have been small and needed their mom. I all the time put them to bed and skim them to sleep.”

Added the author, “People round Gouverneur, the place Mrs. Graves lives, name her Rhody. And she or he likes it.” As for her ideas on the potential for electing a lady governor, her response was completely prescient — “She thinks that it might be less unbelievable to discover a lady senator emerge.” Was it merely a flippant comment, or a understanding glimpse of the longer term? Time would tell.

Yr after yr she was reelected to the Assembly, and continued pushing essential bills that hadn’t previously passed for one purpose or another. There were many new obligations as nicely, including membership on a number of committees overseeing agriculture, the reorganization of state authorities, and welfare and non secular societies. She served on the Joint State Legislative Committee on Farm-to-Market Roads (the first New York lady positioned on a particular committee), looking for options to the dirt-road points that continued to plague upstate farmers. She additionally sought monetary help for one-teacher faculty districts that have been the spine of rural schooling, but have been overburdened by pricey state mandates.

All the whereas, she stored getting reelected, and in November 1931 was returned to workplace for the eighth consecutive yr by one of the largest vote margins of her profession. In 1932, with a concentrate on defending small farmers, she referred to as for a full investigation of milk pricing, citing widespread corruption that left minimal income in the arms of producers. She additionally pushed for modifications in juror legal guidelines, equal guardianship guidelines, and other issues that have been bogged down (or rejected) by lawmakers prior to now.

Whether it was frustration with the Meeting course of, or simply an aspiration to larger workplace, she started considering a run for New York’s Senate, the place no lady had ever served. Among the stark realities to think about: the attempt alone concerned risks that would utterly dismantle her political career. From most perspectives, in truth, absolute failure was the likeliest consequence.

Among the many plethora of reasons to not run for the Senate, a number of have been very compelling. Rhoda was an outlier in ways that most Republicans weren’t. Members have been expected to toe the get together line and comply with the precepts laid out by GOP leaders. In change, they acquired full get together help on most endeavors. However Mrs. Graves had bucked the system at a number of turns. Her public agreement with Democratic Governor Al Smith on certain issues was anathema to Republicans. She rejected the hydropower foyer in favor of local control, and battled different big-business lobbies like phone corporations and milk dealers, in favor of residents who have been overcharged and small farmers who have been struggling to outlive. As she saw it, her main obligation was to district constituents, but as the social gathering noticed it, she refused to pledge allegiance to the complete GOP agenda, and that stored her in constant disfavor. Republican leaders didn’t need a lady within the Meeting back when she first determined to run, however she had gained. Then, yr after yr, they have been perplexed at easy methods to counter the popularity that stored her in workplace.

Apart from all that have been two monumental obstacles to profitable a Senate position. Get together machines have been very powerful, and few have been as entrenched as the one controlling New York’s northernmost counties. At the head was US Congressman Bertrand Snell, who had grow to be a national powerhouse since his election to the House of Representatives in 1915. He gained chairmanship of the highly effective Home Rules Committee in 1923, with an eye fixed in the direction of ultimately turning into Speaker of the Home. That plan fell by the wayside when Republicans misplaced the 1930 midterms, however Snell gained a troublesome battle to grow to be Home Minority Chief, a place he would hold till retirement in 1939. Clearly the man wielded nice energy. Any action by Rhoda towards the Snell-led regime might nicely finish in disaster.

Apart from that primary situation, there was in place a longstanding “gents’s agreement” between Franklin and St. Lawrence County Republicans (to the exclusion of Clinton and Essex Counties, which have been part of the identical Congressional District, but weren’t in the identical Senatorial District). Moderately than battle it out for complete superiority in a closely Republican space, celebration leaders had decided that St. Lawrence County would area candidates for the Home of Representatives in Washington, and Franklin County voters would help them. In trade, Franklin County would nominate state Senate candidates that may be supported by voters in both counties. That casual association, adhered to for many years, was presumed insurmountable for anybody aspiring to office outdoors of those phrases. To interrupt that settlement was to challenge the authority of get together leaders, together with Snell, a longtime beneficiary of the arrangement because it eliminated election competitors.

With all that to think about, Rhoda, who had rocked the GOP boat considerably by operating for the Assembly in 1920, would have to capsize the ship if she hoped to win a Senate run. And the choice was made: if that have been the case, then so be it. Such a move was a minimum of a coup attempt, looking for to wrest management from the Snell group that had long held energy. Her ace within the gap was a large number of loyal followers scattered throughout the district, who, in her estimation, have been purpose sufficient to hitch the race.

Next week, half 4: battling males in a person’s world; taking over a strong political machine.

Pictures: Rhoda Fox Graves, Watertown Every day Normal (1926); headlines, Watertown Day by day Commonplace, (1927); headlines, Rochester Occasions-Union (1928); headlines, The Evening Information, Tonawanda (1932); headlines, Rome Every day Sentinel (1932).

Lawrence P. Gooley

Lawrence Gooley, of Clinton County, is an award-winning writer who has hiked, bushwhacked, climbed, bicycled, explored, and canoed in the Adirondack Mountains for 45 years. With a lifetime love of research, writing, and historical past, he has authored 22 books and greater than 200 articles on the area’s past, and in 2009 organized the North Country Authors within the Plattsburgh space.

His guide Oliver’s Warfare: An Adirondack Insurgent Battles the Rockefeller Fortune gained the Adirondack Literary Award for Greatest Guide of Nonfiction in 2008. Another title, Terror in the Adirondacks: The True Story of Serial Killer Robert F. Garrow, was a regional best-seller for four years operating.

Together with his companion, Jill Jones, Gooley founded Bloated Toe Enterprises in 2004, which has revealed 83 titles up to now. Additionally they supply modifying/proofreading providers, net design, and a variety of PowerPoint shows based mostly on Gooley’s books.

Bloated Toe’s unusual enterprise model was featured in Publishers Weekly in April 2011. The company additionally operates a web-based store to help the work of different regional people. The North Nation Store options more than 100 ebook titles and 60 CDs and DVDs, along with quite a lot of other area merchandise.


View all posts by →



(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = ‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&appId=249643311490&version=v2.3’; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); (document, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));